Is Content the New Cookie?

The move away from cookie-based tracking is a response to increasing public concern around privacy.

This scrutiny comes on the heels of data breaches and scandals that have plagued Facebook, Google, Amazon, Apple, and other Silicon Valley behemoths in recent years.

There’s been much discussion of how search marketers and PPC professionals can prepare for a cookieless web.

But an important question remains: How will the shift from cookies impact SEO? In this post, we’ll explore this change through the lenses of:

  • Personalization in the SERPs.
  • The importance of first-party data.
  • The role of Google Search Console.
  • Information vs. transactional content.
  • Measurement.

Let’s start with what a cookie is and why brands are using them in the first place.

What Is a Cookie?

A cookie is a small text file saved on your device when you visit a website. It stores information about your preferences and other data.


Continue Reading Below

From a consumer perspective, cookies help websites operate more efficiently. They do things like remember passwords and save the items we put into our shopping carts.

On the brand side, they help us understand how visitors use different parts of a website so we can improve the experience for future visitors.

But cookies also help advertisers follow consumers around the web – sometimes far longer and wider than those consumers realize.

These are the “bad” cookies that have resulted in public concern.

The aim of the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), and similar laws is to give consumers visibility into how cookies are being used on websites – especially those that could be classified as “bad.”

This legislation is also designed to give consumers more control over how brands are using their data to create a more seamless user experience, sell to third parties, or for their own marketing/remarketing purposes.

Why Do Companies Use Cookies?

In addition to preserving items in your shopping basket, cookies can do helpful things like preserve your login details for future visits, offer personalized discount codes (like in cart abandonment emails!) or surface recommended content.


Continue Reading Below

“Articles you may be interested in…” and “Products you might like…” are all generated by cookies, for example.

In a bit of logic that is truly baffling, cookies are also used to record what types of cookies (if any) a user has opted to allow to be set in their browser.

Whether cookies are good or bad truly depends on how each brand uses them.

When a site drops a cookie, it follows you around the web and shows content from sites you have visited in the past.

For example, if I am looking for shoes and go to Zappos and do not buy anything, they drop a cookie so I get ads from Zappos as I browse further.

This could result in a helpful reminder to return to buy a pair I liked – or it could be an annoying interruption.

Personalization in the SERPs

Google has a lot of end-user data and uses personalization for organic search results. It looks at your last query, where you are located, and more – but only if you accept cookies.

Personalization and a good user experience (UX) are two ways to establish trust with customers and encourage them to opt in to cookies.

When users do so, the burden is then on the organization to provide a best-in-class UX (continual innovation!) and maintain trust by only using data in ways the consumer has approved.

It is Google’s old motto, “Don’t Be Evil,” but this time we mean it!

If a user declines cookies, the search is depersonalized. Websites targeting broad, less specific queries will tend to benefit, but sites that depend on more specific queries may find it more difficult to reach users.

That’s why it will be even more important for those latter sites to optimize their pages to remain competitive in SERPs.

The Importance of First-Party Data

One big change in the cookieless future is that brands will have to instead tap into first-party data, or data they collect through their websites, apps, or other services. (Third-party data, on the other hand, is collected by an outside provider for advertising purposes.)


Continue Reading Below

Unfortunately for businesses, there are many challenges to gathering quality first-party data.

One is capturing accurate customer actions on a site in order to create a well-rounded profile of who those customers are.

Solutions such as real-time personalization can help capture more relevant information about specific customers through their site usage.

And of course, once you know who they are, you can create the content they need based on their intent and your first-party data.

The Role of Google Search Console

Using Google Search Console will also be more important in a cookieless world.

Google Search Console does not rely on cookies the way Google Analytics does. And because it does not use personal data about users, it is not impeded by laws about cookies.

You can use Google Search Console to get insights on how Google understands your site and get vital information like clicks, impressions, average rankings, click-through rates, etc.

This will help connect the dots, so you can see what content users are engaging with and which keywords perform the best on “user intent.”


Continue Reading Below

Informational v. Transactional Content

Another change we’ll see in this cookieless world is even more emphasis on engaging content that captures users’ interest at every stage.

The good news is this is a permission-based way of getting consumers interested in your products and services.

Marketing is all about creating relationships. The most beautiful and meaningful way to create a relationship is through relevant content that is helpful, useful, engaging, and informative.

Once you understand consumer intent, you have the data and clues you need to attract the right audience through content.

Focusing on the intent of search keywords can result in better click-through rates, conversions, etc. because you are giving people what they want when they want it, and satisfying their informational need.

For example, let’s say I wrote a gated white paper, The Ultimate Guide to Creating an SEO Audit. About 100 people fill out the form to download it.

But then our new business team gets on the phone and discovers only two were genuine leads. What was the problem here?


Continue Reading Below

The issue is this article was mainly about teaching SEO professionals how to perform an audit, which is informational content, or content that educates or entertains.

It was not transactional content, which instead shows how a brand’s products and services can help readers while also reinforcing what the brand is selling and its benefits. Examples of transactional content can include white papers, as well as:

  • Case studies.
  • Partner success stories.
  • Promoted events.
  • Product demonstrations.
  • Product brochures.

If I instead wrote an article like Why Brands Should Invest in an SEO Audit to Improve their ROI by 50%, it would probably have better results because the intent is transactional. It appeals to
brands or business professionals who are looking for SEO services.

Once they read the white paper, they might say, “This is exactly what I need to do. But I need help, so I’m going to contact this company to find more about their audit services.”


Continue Reading Below

This is just one example of why we need to define intent before creating content.

Bonus: Structured Data

Once you get intent right and start ranking for some of your content, it’s time to decorate it with structured data.

Having structured data can help your site show up in rich results and drive more clicks and impressions while also improving your sales and revenue.


Measurement in a cookieless world is going to be extremely important, too.

We need to track offline purchases, map those purchases to an online experience, and show the value (i.e., what role organic search had in the purchase).

That means tracking users who consumed content and then looking for them at the conversion point to figure out if they went to an online store after reading your content.

Work with your analytics team to ensure you are tracking, measuring, and attributing content appropriately to maximize conversions.

There is an increase in brands deploying analytics and other tools on the server-side.


Continue Reading Below

Server-side analytics are generally a more reliable way to measure web engagement and performance. Harder… much harder… but more reliable and more secure, too.

At the same time, users should be made aware of how they are being tracked.

Tech companies are also rolling out tools to help brands navigate the cookieless future and protect consumer privacy.

Microsoft, for example, has announced Parakeet for privacy controls. Meanwhile, Bing API has private search functionality, which is built on keeping consumer data private and addressing many of the concerns advertisers have around data.

This list also includes Google Chrome’s Privacy Sandbox and Apple IDFA.

Wrapping Up

As search engines move away from third-party cookies, it will be harder to follow a customer across digital experiences to get a full picture of their needs, behaviors, and intent.

But I think content is the new cookie, and measurement will help brands better understand what users are looking for.

In turn, brands will be able to use content and measurement to connect the dots across all stages of the fragmented user journey and provide a better user and content experience, while maximizing ROI.


Continue Reading Below

Remember: Cookies were always flawed. We have been in a multi-device/omnichannel world for a while now and measurement solutions have not fully caught up for most brands.

But this is not the end of the online marketing industry.

Cookies are only the end of the marketing industry operating mysteriously behind the scenes. Brands that continue to prioritize the consumer will continue to thrive.

More Resources: